10 Comments

  1. The problem with trying to “make it real” is that the primary source for education these days seems to be social media (most notably, TicTok), and as a social media platform, it is, by definition, fake. Teachers today have to compete with forces far greater than what the classroom can accomplish. If the teacher says A, but social media says B, more times than not, the kids will lean to B, especially if B gets 1,000 likes. So, keeping it real is almost a lost cause.

    Like

    1. I appreciate your thoughts. To my core, I believe that the teacher does not have to say A to compete with B. The teacher helps to design the experience and the students determine what the A, B, and C are. The students create their learning and the teacher facilitates. The experiences and final product must be real.

      Like

      1. Of this we will disagree. Kids do not have the fortitude to create their own learning environment, and that is why they rely on Social Media….to tell them what to think and do. A teacher who “facilitates” a child’s expected learning environment is a teacher who is not “keeping it real”

        Like

      2. I think we are just a bit off in our ideas of what keeping it real is here and perhaps my explanation missed. Keeping it real is to keep the learning experience as close to real life as possible.

        Like

      3. Thanks for clarifying, but that ship sank when they instituted “No Child Left Behind”, because in real life, people who underperform get left behind all the time, would you not agree? Allowing students to progress when they are unable to achieve their current level only exacerbates the idea that working hard is not necessary. Everyone gets a trophy.

        Like

      4. That’s interesting that you bring up No Child Left Behind. I think that law changes nothing about being real. In real life, it takes such a wide variety of skills and abilities to create a successful community. Real education is able to value all of these skills and allow individuals to develop the ones that they are best at and that bring them the most joy. Authentic experiences allow us to teach groups of students in ways that show them the application of skills. Achievement on a selected response test can be a measure but it should never drive what we do or how we are able to teach children their value and to help them develop into adults that are prepared to lead rich and fulfilling lives.

        Like

Leave a reply to pk world 🌎 Cancel reply